Don’t Read This!!

Now here’s something I bet you’ve never thought about. Well I certainly hadn’t when I stepped outside the boundary of ‘science’ and into the world of ‘pop sci’ – aka Betrayed by Nature.

Professional evisceration

To get sciency stuff published you have to endure the dread process of ‘peer review’. Your paper is sent to experts who apply their giant brains, formidable grasp of the subject and sadistic natures to a completely impartial assessment of whether it is of sufficient merit to appear in whichever journal you have favoured with your attentions. Or, put another way, it gets put through a mincer that takes fiendish delight in dissecting every syllable, making ‘suggestions’ that amount to a total re-write and demanding a further series of experiments (to ‘solidify’ the data) that would see you past retirement, if not into the beckoning abyss beyond. If, by combining grovelling submission, bartering, and deviousness you finally get the thing into print, what happens next? Nothing. Not a squeak. The vast majority of papers disappear as surely as if dropped into the Mariana Trench in a lead-lined box. Just occasionally, if a few of the co-authors have Nobel Prizes, you might find your opus clambering up one or another citation index, meaning that some other bunch of numpties have mentioned it in their own feeble scribblings – doesn’t mean they actually read it, of course. And that’s it.

Pop in public

But out in the real world ‘pop’ stuff comes out – and then gets reviewed – so it’s like writing chick-lit (I’ve no idea what that is but I quite fancy having a go). And the critics turn up from all over the place. Their views get emailed to you by well-intentioned friends, someone in the coffee queue regales you (“just seen ….”) or you stumble over one when your surfing fingers inadvertently hit ‘sci reviews’ instead of ‘sex reviews.’

So Monty Python was wrong – you do expect The Spanish Inquisition – that any minute you’ll be dragged naked through the streets of Cambridge – well, emotionally at least. So, after all that, a lady friend has told me to be a man (very naughty to have peeked) and to bravely blog reviews received.

You have been warned!

Reviews of BETRAYED BY NATURE The War on Cancer by Robin Hesketh Palgrave Macmillan 272 pp. £16.99 (2012)

1.  William Hanson, MD, author of The Edge of Medicine: Dr. Hesketh brings an expert’s easy familiarity and depth to this comprehensive, at times almost affectionate, look at a deadly adversary. He tells us what cancer is, what causes it, what we can do to prevent it and how we are systematically battling the disease on many fronts.

2.  Kirkus Reviews (The World’s Toughest Book Critics) 1 March 2012:  Informative, optimistic tour of the science of cancer: Hesketh (Biochemistry/Cambridge Univ.), familiar to lay audiences from BBC radio and TV, opens Part 1 with a capsule history of cancer, ranging from papyrus records of ancient Egypt to the scientific breakthroughs of the 21st century. He follows with a look at the distribution of different types of cancers around the world and what the data suggests about cancer’s causes. Matters get technical in Part 2, but the author assumes little previous knowledge on the part of readers; he takes time to explain DNA, RNA, genes, chromosomes and how some genes mutate into cancer genes. In Part 3 he tackles cancer cells and the behavior of tumors. Throughout Parts 2 and 3, relatively simple diagrams and some black-and-white photographs help to clarify the technical discussions. For most readers, the final section – “Where Are We? Where Are We Going?” – will be of greatest interest. Here Hesketh explains how genome sequencing has begun to change how cancers are diagnosed and classified, and the promise this holds for therapy. We are at the beginning, he writes, of the era of personalized medicine, which holds the promise that we will someday be able to detect the threat of cancer long before it manifests itself by sequencing an individual’s genome and using that information to design an individualized therapeutic strategy. The back matter includes a helpful glossary and two delightful odes to cancer, one written in 1964 by the noted geneticist (and cancer patient) J.B.S. Haldane and the other a modern version by Hesketh.

Despite the author’s occasionally breezy style – “cancer is jolly complicated” – this is not a book to breeze through, but rather a solid account of how cancer works, how it has been combated and what the future holds for its treatment.

https://www.kirkusreviews.com/search/?q=hesketh&x=16&y=13

3.  Nature 485, 579 (31 May 2012): It afflicts one in three people globally and kills more than 7 million a year. Yet cancer is, at base, simply an abnormal growth of cells. In this admirably clear overview, biochemist Robin Hesketh gives us the history, basic science and characteristics of cancer cells, charting how tumours spread and detailing genetics, detection, therapies and drugs. There is much to fascinate — from eighteenth-century physician Percivall Pott’s deduction that there was a link between soot and scrotal cancer in chimney sweeps, to the challenges of treating the biological “hodgepodge” that is a tumour.

http://libsta28.lib.cam.ac.uk:2157/nature/journal/v485/n7400/full/485579a.html

4.  John P. Moore, Professor of Microbiology and Immunology, Weill Cornell: In Betrayed by Nature, Robin Hesketh melds medicine, science and history to create a clear and highly readable explanation of the complexities of cancer.

5.  Interview on The Leonard Lopate Show: lopate050812apod.mp3

6.  For Amazon reviews see their web site.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s